Sheetz Ice Cream Menu 2026: Prices, Flavors & Customization

Craving something cold, creamy, and satisfying at 2 AM? Sheetz has you covered. The convenience store chain known for its Made-To-Order® food also serves up an impressive lineup of ice cream treats from customizable sundaes to thick milkshakes available 24/7/365.

What Makes Sheetz Ice Cream Different?

Sheetz doesn’t just sell pre-packaged ice cream. Their Shweetz Bakery concept extends to frozen desserts, offering hand-crafted treats with endless customization options. You can order through their mobile app, customize toppings at the kiosk, or grab ready-made options from the freezer case.

Key advantages

Available around the clock at most locations
Fully customizable toppings and mix-ins
Competitive pricing compared to specialty ice cream shops
Convenient ordering via the Sheetz app for quick pickup

Sheetz Ice Cream Menu: Flavors & Prices

Based on menu data from February 2026, here’s what you’ll find at Sheetz locations. Note: Prices vary by location, and the figures below represent averages from third-party menu sites. Always verify current pricing through the Sheetz app or your local store.

Classic Ice Cream Flavors

Flavor	Size Options	Price Range	Calories
Mint Chocolate Chip	S / M / L	$2.99 – $4.99	~380
Coffee Caramel Crunch	S / M / L	$3.49 – $5.49	~410
Cookie Dough Blast	S / M / L	$3.49 – $5.49	~460
Berry Sorbet (dairy-free)	S / M / L	$2.99 – $4.99	~290

Sundaes & Specialty Treats

Item	Price	Calories
Chocolate Fudge Sundae	$3.99	420
Peanut Butter Cup Delight	$4.49	450
Ben & Jerry’s Sundae	$6.49	600

What Are Sheetz Milkshakes Called?

Sheetz refers to their milkshakes as “Shakerz” on some menu boards, though “milkshakes” appears more commonly. These thick, creamy blends come in classic and creative flavors.

Popular Milkshake Options

Flavor	Size	Price	Calories
Vanilla Milkshake	Regular	$4.69	699
Chocolate Milkshake	Regular	$4.69	778
Strawberry Milkshake	Regular	$4.69	728
Cookies-n-Cream	Regular	$5.19	1,074
Banana Milkshake	Regular	$4.69	865
Peanut Butter Milkshake	Regular	$4.69	1,363

Premium Cheezecake Shakez

Fruit Fuzion Cheezecake: $5.49 (938 cal)
Peanut Butter Brownie Cheezecake: $5.99
White Chocolate Raspberry Cheezecake: $6.48

How to Customize Your Sheetz Ice Cream

One of the biggest draws of Sheetz ice cream is the ability to build your perfect dessert. Here’s how to make the most of their customization options:

Step 1: Choose Your Base

Start with a flavor from their ice cream menu or opt for a milkshake base. You can mix two flavors if you’re feeling adventurous.

Step 2: Add Mix-Ins & Toppings

Sheetz offers an array of toppings at no extra charge (though premium options may cost more):

Candies: Oreo crumbles, Reese’s pieces, M&M’s, cookie dough chunks
Sauces: Hot fudge, caramel, strawberry, peanut butter
Extras: Whipped cream, sprinkles, cherries, chopped nuts

Step 3: Turn It Into Something New

Sundae: Add warm fudge and whipped cream
Float: Combine with soda or cold brew coffee
Affogato-style: Pour espresso over vanilla ice cream

Signature Build Ideas

The “Inner Freak” Sundae

Base: Cookie Dough Blast ice cream
Mix-ins: Crushed Oreos + brownie bites
Toppings: Hot fudge + caramel drizzle + whipped cream

Late-Night Energy Boost

Base: Coffee Caramel Crunch
Addition: Shot of espresso poured over (affogato-style)
Topping: Chocolate-covered espresso beans

Salty-Sweet Perfection

Base: Peanut Butter Cup Delight
Mix-ins: Pretzel pieces + mini chocolate chips
Topping: Sea salt + caramel

Can You Pair Sheetz Ice Cream With Food?

Absolutely. Sheetz’s 24/7 menu means you can create unique food-and-dessert combos:

Sweet & Savory Pairings

Curly Fryz + Vanilla Shake: Dip salty fries into a cold shake for the classic diner experience
Big Mozz Burger + Berry Sorbet: Balance a rich burger with a light, fruity palate cleanser
Hot Dog + Cookies-n-Cream Shake: A nostalgic boardwalk-style combo

Coffee Shop Vibes

Sheetz Bros. Coffee + Mint Chocolate Chip: Pair a hot latte with a refreshing scoop
Cold Brew + Peanut Butter Milkshake: The ultimate caffeine-and-dessert power combo

Ordering Sheetz Ice Cream: App vs. In-Store

Using the Sheetz App

The Sheetz mobile app lets you:

Browse the full ice cream menu with real-time pricing
Customize your order with specific toppings
Schedule pickup for a specific time
Track your order status
Pay with card, Apple Pay, Google Pay, or Sheetz gift cards

Pro tip: Check the app for promotions. Sheetz occasionally offers discounts on milkshakes and desserts through their My Sheetz Rewardz program.

Ordering at the Kiosk

Prefer to build your dessert in person? Use the touchscreen kiosk inside any Sheetz location. The visual interface makes it easy to see all topping options and pricing before you commit.

Wait times: Most ice cream orders are ready in 5-10 minutes. Avoid peak hours (11 AM–6 PM) if you’re in a rush, as wait times can extend to 15 minutes during busy periods.

Are Sheetz Ice Cream Prices the Same Everywhere?

No. Pricing varies by location and region. Urban areas and highway rest stops may charge slightly more than suburban stores. The prices listed in this guide represent averages from unofficial menu sources as of February 2026.

To find exact pricing

Check the Sheetz mobile app for your specific location
Call your local store
Visit the in-store kiosk to view live menu pricing

Frequently Asked Questions

How many calories are in a Sheetz milkshake?

Sheetz milkshakes range from 617 calories (Blue Raspberry) to 1,363 calories (Peanut Butter). Most regular-sized shakes contain 700-900 calories. Check the nutrition calculator on the Sheetz app for specific values.

What’s the most popular ice cream flavor at Sheetz?

Based on menu prominence and online reviews, Cookies-n-Cream Milkshake and Peanut Butter Cup Delight are consistently top sellers. Mint Chocolate Chip is the most popular scoop flavor.

Does Sheetz have dairy-free ice cream options?

Yes. Berry Sorbet is a dairy-free option with approximately 290 calories per serving. It contains no milk or cream, making it suitable for lactose-intolerant customers.

How much does a Ben & Jerry’s sundae cost at Sheetz?

Ben & Jerry’s sundaes are priced at $6.49 and contain approximately 600 calories. This is Sheetz’s premium sundae option.

Can I order Sheetz ice cream for delivery?

Yes, through DoorDash and Uber Eats in select locations. Availability varies by store. Check the Sheetz app or third-party delivery apps to confirm.

Are Sheetz ice cream portions generous?

Yes. Customer reviews consistently note that portions are larger than expected, especially for the price point. A regular milkshake typically fills a 16-20 oz cup.

What’s the cheapest ice cream option at Sheetz?

Berry Sorbet and Mint Chocolate Chip in small sizes start at $2.99, making them the most budget-friendly options. Ready-to-eat items like MTgo! parfaits start at $3.99.

How fresh is Sheetz ice cream?

According to the official Sheetz website, Shweetz items are “hand-crafted by master chefs and baked fresh daily.” While specific ice cream preparation details aren’t disclosed, the quality matches or exceeds typical convenience store offerings.

Can I use My Sheetz Rewardz points on ice cream?

Yes. Sheetz Rewardz members earn points on all purchases, including ice cream and milkshakes. Points can be redeemed for discounts on future orders.

What time does Sheetz stop serving ice cream?

Sheetz serves ice cream 24/7/365 at most locations. However, some stores may temporarily pause Made-To-Order items during overnight restocking (typically 2-4 AM). Check with your local store or use the app to confirm availability.

Why Sheetz Ice Cream Is Worth the Stop

Sheetz has quietly built one of the most versatile ice cream menus in the convenience store category. The combination of quality ingredients, endless customization, competitive pricing, and 24/7 availability makes it a legitimate alternative to traditional ice cream parlors.

Ready to customize your perfect frozen treat? Download the Sheetz app and explore the full ice cream menu with real-time pricing for your location. Your next late-night dessert run just got a whole lot sweeter.