Sheetz MTO Menu: Fresh, Custom Meals Made Your Way in 2025
Craving food that’s made exactly the way you like it, anytime, anywhere? That’s where the Sheetz MTO menu comes in. MTO, or Made to Order, lets you take full control of your meal from breakfast burritos and stacked burgers to fresh salads, subs, and even personal pizzas.
With Sheetz, every order is prepared fresh on the spot, giving you endless customization options, 24/7 availability, and wallet friendly prices. Whether you’re a night owl grabbing a late night snack or starting your day with a hearty breakfast, the Sheetz mto food ensures your cravings are always satisfied your way.
What is Sheetz Made-To-Order Menu?
The sheetz mto short for Made to Order is the heart of the Sheetz experience, offering fresh, fully customizable meals at over 750 locations across Pennsylvania, Virginia, and Maryland. Since introducing MTO in 1995, Sheetz Inc has transformed fast food into a personal dining adventure, letting you build every meal from scratch.
Whether you’re craving a Signature Burger, a Chicken Tender Sub, a Breakfast Burrito, or a Personal Pizza, you decide the bread, proteins, cheese, toppings, and sauces. Every item is prepared fresh when you order no pre packed boxes, no reheated food, and no limits on flavor. Fans of Sheetz love the freedom to create their perfect meal, whether they’re ordering in store at a touchscreen kiosk, through the Sheetz mobile app, or grabbing it from the drive thru.
Why MTO Sheetz Menu is a Fan Favorite?
The MTO Menu Sheetz has earned its spot as a fan favorite because it puts you in complete control of your meal. From the Signature Burger to the Grilled Chicken Salad or a customizable Breakfast Burrito, every item is freshly made using the ingredients you choose. Fans love the all day availability whether it’s breakfast at 3 PM or a late night Chicken Tender Sub, Sheetz Inc ensures you’re never limited by time.
The menu offers affordable options without compromising quality, with favorites like the Personal Pizza or Veggie Wrap priced for every budget. Plus, the Sheetz Rewards program lets loyal customers earn points and free food, stacking extra value on top of an already unbeatable experience. With endless variety, full customization, and fresh, hot meals made to order, it’s no wonder the Sheetz mto keeps customers coming back.
Best Sheetz MTO Menu Items to Try
Overwhelmed by choices on the Sheetz MTO food? Here’s a list of top fan favorite items, combining breakfast, subs, burgers, bowls, sides, and drinks, all made fresh and fully customizable. These picks reflect popular choices from Sheetz locations in Pennsylvania, Virginia, and Maryland and highlight why Sheetz Inc continues to stand out among like Wawa, Casey’s, and Bucee’s.
Category | Menu Item | Starting Price | Description |
Breakfast | Breakfast Burrito Shmuffin French Toast Sticks | $2.79 $3.49 $3.99 | Eggs, your choice of sausage or bacon, cheese, and salsa wrapped in a soft tortilla. |
Subs & Sandwiches | Chicken Tender Sub Turkey Sub Philly Dog | $6.99 $5.99 $4.49 | Crispy chicken tenders with your choice of toppings and Boom Boom sauce. |
Burgers & Bowls | Signature Burger MTO Burger Teriyaki Chicken Bowl | $5.29 $4.99 $7.49 | Fresh beef patty with customizable toppings and sauces. |
Sides & Snacks | Loaded Curly Fries Mac ‘n’ Cheese Bites Fryz | $3.89 $3.99 $2.49 | Fries topped with bacon, jalapeños, cheese, and your choice of sauce. |
Drinks & Smoothies | Classic Milkshake Fruit Smoothie | $3.99 $3.49 | Chocolate, vanilla, Oreo, and seasonal flavors. |
Sheetz MTO vs. the Competition
Sheetz MTO stands out for fresh, customizable meals compared to Wawa, Casey’s, and Buc-ee’s. From Signature Burgers to Breakfast Burritos and Personal Pizzas, Sheetz offers full control, 24/7 availability, and Sheetz Rewards, giving it an edge over competitors who focus on pre made or limited options.
Feature / Chain | Sheetz | Wawa | Casey’s | Buc-ee’s |
Customization | Fully customizable meals (subs, burgers, wraps, bowls, pizzas) | Limited customization on hoagies | Mostly pre-made pizzas and sandwiches | Limited to pre-made BBQ and snacks |
Menu Variety | Breakfast, lunch, dinner, sides, desserts, drinks, smoothies | Hoagies, coffee, limited breakfast | Pizza, sandwiches, breakfast items | BBQ, snacks, sandwiches |
Availability | 24/7 at most locations | Varies by location; not always 24/7 | Limited hours | Limited hours; primarily highway locations |
Ordering Options | In store kiosk, mobile app, drive thru, pickup | In-store, mobile app | In-store, limited online | In-store only |
Rewards / Loyalty | Sheetz Rewards program (points & free food) | Wawa Rewards | Casey’s Rewards | None |
Freshness | Made-to-order on demand | Some items pre-made | Mostly pre-made | Pre-made items only |
Sheetz MTO Menu Hacks and What’s New
Take your Sheetz MTO menu experience to the next level with insider hacks and the latest 2025 updates. Fans love customizing classics like the MTO Burger, Chicken Tender Sub, or Breakfast Burrito with extras such as mac ‘n’ cheese bites, hashbrowns, or Boom Boom sauce. You can even create secret combos, like a Taco Burger with taco toppings on a burger patty, or swap fries for apple slices for a lighter option.
What’s new in 2025? Sheetz Inc introduced fresh additions like MTO Bowls, including the Southwest Steak Bowl with quinoa and peppers, expanded vegan options with plant based patties and dairy free cheese, and price updates on popular items like the Shmuffin and Breakfast Burrito. These changes make the menu even more customizable, affordable, and delicious, keeping loyal fans and new customers coming back for more.
Read More: Sheetz Menu with Pictures
How to Order MTO Menu from the Sheetz
Ordering from the Sheetz MTO Menuis simple, fast, and fully customizable, whether you’re at a Sheetz Inc location in Pennsylvania, Virginia, or Maryland or using the Sheetz mobile app. Here’s how to get your perfect meal:
Choose Your Method:
- Touchscreen Kiosk: Tap through the menu inside Sheetz to build your meal step by step.
- Sheetz Mobile App: Customize, pay, and schedule pickup or opt for delivery where available.
- Drive-Thru or Cashier: Place your order verbally if you prefer.
Build Your Meal:
- Pick a base like a sub, wrap, burger, or bowl.
- Add proteins such as chicken, steak, or eggs.
- Select cheese like Swiss, cheddar, or pepper jack.
- Load toppings, sauces, and extras like Boom Boom sauce, hashbrowns, or mac ‘n’ cheese bites.
Finalize & Pick Up:
- Wait 3–5 minutes while your meal is freshly prepared.
- Grab a drink, sauces, and enjoy a fully customized MTO Burger, Grilled Chicken Salad, or Breakfast Burrito.
Conclusion
The Sheetz MTO menu isn’t just about convenience it’s about freedom, freshness, and flavor made your way. Whether you’re in the mood for a Signature Burger, a Breakfast Burrito, or a fully loaded Chicken Tender Sub, Sheetz lets you customize every detail to match your craving. With 24/7 availability, affordable prices, and easy ordering through the Sheetz app, drive-thru, or in-store kiosks, you’re always just a few taps away from your perfect meal. So next time you stop by Sheetz, skip the ordinary and create something extraordinary with the Made To Order menu because at Sheetz, every bite is made just for you.